Monday, June 26, 2017

Adrian H. Joline: Author, Autograph Collector, and Dofob

I plead guilty to the charge of being a dreary old fool over books, but chiefly old books, for they have a settled and permanent character which no one may impeach. We may be tolerably sure about them; they are generally what they seem to be, with their broad margins, their solid, substantial type, and their charming air of dignity. Most of the books of our day are unworthy of absolute confidence, and their paper, their binding, and their typography are a source of grief to the judicious. The man whose literary pabulum is sufficiently supplied by his daily newspaper may ask why an old book, with its aged and decayed covers, is better than a new one with that outward adornment of gilt which some publishers delight to lavish upon us. The sagacious Dofob will not undertake the task of breaking his way into the solid density of such a mind or of explaining to him the reason, for the game is not worth the candle....
Adrian H. Joline
The Deliberations of a Dofob
From: At the Library Table, 1910

Here are some reviews of At the Library Table:

You will not find Adrian H. Joline or his book, At the Library Table, listed in Winslow L. Webber's 1937 bio-bibliography, Books about Books, or in Carl L. Cannon's 1941 book, American Book Collectors and Collecting.  Nor will you find The Diversions of a Book-Lover, Joline's best book about books, listed in Webber or Cannon either.  It may very well be that Adrian H. Joline's reputation as an autograph collector completely overshadowed his reputation as a book collector.   Joline had an extensive autograph collection that was second to none.  He had complete sets of the autographs of the Signers of the Declaration of Independence, the Presidents, Vice Presidents,  Secretaries of State, Secretaries of War and more.  Moreover, he wrote books about autograph collecting, and wrote a column for Walter R. Benjamin's periodical on autograph collecting, The Collector.   

The late Donald C. Dickinson recognized Adrian H. Joline's significance as a book collector  and included him in his 1986 book, Dictionary of American Book Collectors.  And Dickinson listed The Diversions of a Book-Lover and At the Library Table as two of the three sources for his bibliography, the other source being Meditations of an Autograph Collector, also by Joline.

Adrian H. Joline (1850-1912) graduated from the College of New Jersey, Princeton, in 1870 and Columbia Law School in 1872, and was active in both alumni organizations (Joline Hall, a dormitory at Princeton, was named after him).   It is said that Joline died of sheer exhaustion on Oct, 15, 1912, mostly from overwork as Receiver of the Metropolitan Street Railways.  According to, at the time of his death, Joline was senior partner of the firm of Joline, Rathbone & Larkin, and director of the following railway and insurance companies: Albany & Susquehana Railroad Company, American & Foreign Marine Insurance Company, National Surety Company,  and United Traction & Electric Company.  He was also the director of the Chatham-Phenix National Bank and the Receiver of the Metropolitan Street Railways.

Adrian H. Joline was a member of the Grolier Club of New York, the Bibliophile Society of Boston, and the Caxton Club of Chicago.  He was also a member of the Society of the Dofobs of Chicago.  Yes, the Dofobs were real!  The acronym reportedly stands for Damned Old Fools Over Books.  But if one chooses, the first word can be replaced with Darned or Dreary.   Joline's essay, "Deliberations of a Dofob," was first published in The Second Book of the Dofobs in 1909.  Only 50 copies were printed.  And I do not have a copy.

Nor do I have a copy of Joline's first book on autographs, Meditations of an Autograph Collector, published in 1902.  I do, however, have a copy of his first and best book about books, The Diversions of a Book-Lover, published in 1903.  Joline combined both hobbies, extra-illustrating his books with autograph letters and portraits.

His next book, The Book Collector and Other Papers was privately printed in 1904 in an edition of 150 copies.  And as Joline mentioned in the Preforatory Note, he wrote the papers for his friends:

Technically, I don't consider this book to be a book about books because the first paper is the only essay that is related to book collecting.  I also have a copy of the Third Year Book of the Bibliophile Society of Boston in which that essay first appeared.  An excellent essay it is!

Joline himself leveled aspersions on his choice of title for his 1907 book, The Autograph Hunter and Other Papers:

Joline's friend, the renowned jurist John H. Dillon (1831-1914) was responsible for the inclusion of the paper on George Payne Rainsford James in this book.  In the latter part of 1906, Joline had thirty copies of the James essay printed, and presented  Copy No. 18 to Dillon.  Pasted in the book is Joline's A.L.S. to Dillon, as well as a copy of Dillon's response to Joline.

In his response, Dillon wrote:
I have a book-lover's fondness for a scarce or rare volume (one of thirty for example), but still I am sorry that your delightful book is not regularly published so that the many might enjoy it as well as the few fortunate and favored dozens of the author.

I have a rather humorous footnote to add regarding the purchase of this book.  I acquired it on eBay,  and the seller wrote that one of the letters was from George Payne Rainsford James.  That would have been "heavenly," especially since James died forty-six and a half years before the letter was written!

Next up is Joline's 1910 book, At the Library Table.  I acquired my copy at Larry McMurtry's book town, Archer City, in June 2011.

Adrian H. Joline presented this copy to Joseph M Andreini, a member of the Grolier Club, the American Bookplate Society, and the Collectors' Club (stamp collecting).

Above Joline's inscription,  a former owner – definitely not Andreini or McMurtry – wrote that the book At the Library Table was "Abt Autograph Collecting!"

Adreini had a high respect for Joline, and in the book, Adreini inserted an advert from George D. Smith about the book;  a clipping about Joline from a May 1911 issue of the periodical, The Smart Set; an unidentified clipping of a portrait of Ainsworth; and an obituary notice from the Oct 16, 1912 issue of the New York Herald.  I call attention to the newspaper headline of the obit: ADRIAN H. JOLINE, LAWYER, IS DEAD:  His Health Shattered by Excessive Work as Receiver of Metropolitian Street Railways:

Two of Joline's books were printed in 1911, Peapack Papers and Edgehill Essays.  Currently, there is only one copy of the first edition of Peapack Papers  listed on the web, but it is too rich for me at $150.   I did, however read the book online at .  The chapters on trifles, collecting of books, and reading are right up my alley, while the very last chapter in the book provides an insight into Joline's frustrations as Receiver of Metropolitan Street Railways.

Tuesday, May 30, 2017

Augustine Birrell: That Charming and Graceful Writer...

...that charming and graceful writer who has lately deserted the turmoil of literature for the peace of the House of Commons. I mean the author of Obiter Dicta.

                                    The Critic as Artist by Oscar Wilde, 1891

Augustine Birrell (1850-1933) was a barrister by trade who became a popular author in 1884 and then an elected politician in 1889.  But he never deserted  the turmoil of literature while he was in the House of Commons.  Moreover, he may have been at peace in the House of Commons, but not so in the latter part of his years as Chief  Secretary of Ireland.  More on that later.

Augustine Birrell's law practice was slowly growing when in 1879 his wife of thirteen months died in childbirth along with their infant daughter.  Birrell's younger sister Olive came to live with him.  And in his autobiography, Things Past Redress, published posthumously, Birrell wrote:
So far as I could see there was no reason why I should not continue, though without much brightness of hope, to go down to my Chambers in Lincoln's Inn and return home at night to my sister and my library till the end of my days.
But that was not to be.  Birrell (pronounced Beer-ill) found solace in writing.  He and some of his friends wrote papers "on things in general and books in particular."  He invited his friends to join him in publishing their papers for private circulation.  Only one of his friends, George Radford, submitted a piece, an essay on Falstaff.  Birrell wrote all the other essays:

In 1884,  Birrell asked the publisher Eliot Stock how much it would cost to print 100 copies of the book,   Stock suggested they print 250 copies and send a dozen copies to the newspapers.  The book, Obiter Dicta, received more than favorable reviews, the 250 copies quickly sold out, and the book was quickly reprinted several times in editions of 500 copies.   Here is an image of the title page of the fourth edition.  The author's name is not included on the title page:

Birrell followed up with a second series of Obiter Dicta in 1887.  And this time his name was on the title page:

My copies of Obiter Dicta were published in New York in 1901 by Charles Scribner's Sons:

Here's the Table of Contents for the Second Series:

Essays on Johnson, Burke, Lamb, Emerson and more all in one book? Yes!  I will note that I used a quote from Birrell's essay, 'The Muse of History," in a book of essays the Caxton Club published in 2011.  More on that later.

The American critic Richard Henry Stoddard wrote a nice piece about Augustine Birrell which appeared in the November 1887 issue of The Book Buyer:

1887 was a good year for Augustine Birrell.  That was the year he met Eleanor Tennyson, ne√© Locker, the widow of Lionel Tennyson, Alfred Tennyson's son, and the daughter of the book collector Frederick Locker-Lampson.  For Birrell, it was love at first sight.  They were married a year later.  As for his new father-in-law, Birrell was a book collector himself, with a library of thousands of books.  So they got along splendidly!

In 1892, Eliot Stock and Scribner's published Birrell's book, Res Judicat√¶.  My copy belonged to Kermit Roosevelt.  And I wrote about the history of the book on this very blog in Feb 2013.

The next Birrell book that I have in my library is Men, Women and Books, first published by Stock and Scribner's in 1894.  And, yes, that is a different essay on Dr. Johnson:

Augustine Birrell had a unique way with words both written and spoken. He describes his style of writing in his autobiography:
I see I have forgotten to say anything about the "style" of my essays. The style has, I know, been animadverted upon by purists and pedants, two classes of men on whom I have fawned all my life, but who disapprove of me all the same. Their complaints amount to this. My sentences, so they say, go slithering along, half down a page, and then end up with a cracker tied to their tails....

Birrell was popular on both sides of the Atlantic, as witnessed by the articles in The Academy in London, and The Literary World in New York.

In 1901, Eliot Stock and Scribner's published another book of Birrell's essays, but with different titles, although the contents were identical. In London it was entitled Miscellanies  and in New York it was entitled Essays and Addresses.  I have the New York edition, and my copy was formerly owned by the American paper box magnate, Lyman Strong Spitzer:

In 1904, Birrell edited a six-volume edition of Boswell's Life of Johnson for the publishers Archibald Constable and Co. in London and The Old Corner Book Store in Boston:

I have to say that my jaw dropped when I read the first three paragraphs of Birrell's Introduction to this book:
More than sixty years ago, Carlyle, writing in Fraser's Magazine, observed in that manner of his which has now become part of our incorporate existence, that the new edition of Boswell, then lately undertaken by Mr. Croker, was a praiseworthy but no miraculous procedure––in no way an event in universal history, and indeed in very truth one of the most insignificant of things.
   If that were true in 1832 of so pretentious an edition of Boswell's Johnson as Mr. Croker's, the insignificance of the present edition is almost startling. Boswell's immortal biography has been reprinted many times since the date of Carlyle's famous article, and in our immediate hour we have the advantage of re-reading it in the careful and interesting edition of the late Mr. Napier, as well as in the splendid volumes of my revered friend, Dr. Birkbeck Hill, whose eager and unresting toil and minute diligence has left scarce anything behind him for even the most humble-minded of gleaners in the Johnsonian fields.
   When you know you must be beaten, the wisest course is to decline competition....

In the Name of the Bodleian was the title of Birrell's next book of essays, first published in 1905:

In 1910, Augustine Birrell wrote the Introduction for the Victoria Edition of the Crowned Masterpieces of Eloquence.  I still remember carrying these ten heavy volumes from a bookstore in Cambridge, England and across the parade grounds to my van:

Here is the last paragraph of Birrell's Introduction:
Orators, happily for us, differ so hugely one from another, that the only thing to do is what is done here––to heap them all together, the good and the bad; him whose course is fertilizing like that of a great river and him who runs glittering like a brook; the old and the new, from the East and from the West, and then to submit them as a whole to the judgment of mankind and the mercy of heaven.

In 1917, August Birrell had 100 copies of Aphorisms on Authors and Their Ways privately printed, all aphorisms of which were taken from Johnson's Lives of the Poets.  Birrell presented this particular copy to the "Dean of Norwich," the clergyman, author, and poet, Henry Charles Beeching (1859-1919).

More Obiter Dicta was  published in 1924.  Birrell thought this might be his last book of essays and in the preface he "dedicated" the book to himself (this wass the last book that he himself wrote the preface or introduction).  All the essays were previously published in periodicals, but as far as I can tell, this is the first time the essays appeared in book form.

In 1926,  George G. Harrap & Co. published  several of Birrell's essays for its series, Essays of To-Day and Yesterday.  The essay on George Borrow appears to be the only essay previously printed in book form.  All the others were previously published in periodicals.

In 1930, Chatto and Windus published a book of Birrell's essays:  Et Cetera.  I particularly enjoyed the essay about James Boswell, "Boswell Disrobed!"

The last book by Birrell in my library is his autobiography, Things Past Redress, which was published in 1937 after his death. It is an ex-lib copy, but because of the information provided between its covers, it is well worth every penny I paid for it.  Birrell devotes an entire chapter about Ireland, which you will read about shortly.

I would be remiss if I did not have a copy of the character sketch of his father-in-law, Frederick Locker-Lampson, that Augustine Birrell wrote in 1920.  A copy from Zubal Books is on its way!   I seem to be in the early stages of developing an offshoot collection of Frederick Locker-Lampson.  My Australian friend, the Johnsonian, John Byrne "traded" me a copy of  Alfred Tennyson, Frederick Locker and Augustine Birrell:  A Talk Given to the Rowfant Club by Sir Charles Tennyson on 28 September 1962.

And just recently I acquired a Locker-Lampson A. L. S. for my autograph letter collection.  Locker-Lampson was requesting four copies of his book, London Lyrics, from his publisher, Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner and Co.

 I should mention that I am not a "completist."  There are a few books Birrell wrote that I don't "need" to have in my library:  his books on Bronte, Hazlitt, Marvell, and Lockwood.  There are a few other books that contain essays previously published in book form.  eg: Stock's Collected Essays, 1899 contains the essays in the two Obiter Dicta books.

I am fortunate to have three books in my library that were formerly owned by Augustine Birrell.

Tales and Sketches (Treasure House of Tales) by Benjamin Disraeli, London: William Paterson, 1891

The Coming of the Friars and Other Historic Essays by Augustus Jessopp, London:  T. Fisher Unwin, 1889.  This copy first belonged to Augustine Birrell and then Vincent Starrett.  In 1941, Christopher Morley found it in the Argus Bookshop in Chicago.  I wrote a blog post about this find in April 2009, Birrell, Starrett, Morley, But Who is O.M.?  The book itself is in the state of semi-repair (I need to replace the endpapers).

The third book in my library formerly owned by Augustine Birrell is his annotated copy of  Lord Acton's Lectures on the French Revolution, London:  Macmillan  and Co., 1910.  Birrell bought this book in Vevey-Suisse in 1910.

Birrell "entered marginalia no less than forty-six times, ranging from a date, to  a witty word, to a few sentences."

A Birrell Zinger from Lord Acton's Book:

In the very first paragraph of this post, I  mentioned Augustine Birrell being the Chief Secretary of Ireland.  And I bought Birrell's copy of Lord Acton's Lectures on the French Revolution specifically for that reason.  But Birrell did not become the Chief Secretary of Ireland overnight.

His political career actually began in 1885 and 1886 when he twice ran unsuccessfully for a seat in the House of Commons.  He was elected to the House of Commons in 1889, was re-elected in 1892 and 1895, but was defeated in 1900.  In his autobiography, he referred to his years in Parliament "as the best years of my life."  In 1906, Birrell was back in Parliament, but not for long.  In February 1907, the Right Honorable Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman appointed Augustine Birrrell the Chief Secretary of Ireland, a position he would retain until the Easter Rising of April 1916.

Birrell made his first blunder after his initial briefing on Ireland.   He declared "that Ireland had never been in so peaceful a state for the last four hundred years!"  Naturally, when the Easter Rising occurred in 1916, the blame was placed on Birrell and he was sacked.  As Chief Secretary, he should have known what was going on in Ireland.

In his Obiter Dicta essay, "The Muse of History," Birrell wrote:
The task of the historian, as here explained, is not merely to tell us the story of the past, and thus gratify our curiosity, but, pursuing a practical object, to seek to modify our views of the present and help us in our forecasts of the future....
Augustine Birrell acquired Lord Acton's Lectures on the French Revolution in 1910.  And he wrote his thoughts about the book's contents in the margins.  I wondered if Birrell applied anything he learned about the French Revolution to the situation at hand in Ireland.  But it appears that Birrell did not pay much attention to Lord Acton's book until after he was sacked in 1916.  Although Birrell acquired the book in 1910, the earliest dated marginalia entry is from 1919.

Augustine Birrell was Chief Secretary of Ireland from 1907 to 1916.  He was successful in his first four years, particularly in making gains in Irish education.  But he was bogged down with his wife's medical problems afterwards.  In 1911, Eleanor Birrell was diagnosed with an inoperable brain tumor.  In his book, Turning Points of the Irish Revolution, B. Grob-Fitzgibbon reports that all Augustine Birrell  wanted to do at the time was to retire to England with his wife.  But, with a war going on, that was not to be.  Birrell and his wife remained in Ireland.  And  Birrell lost interest in Ireland's problems.  His wife died in March 1915.  As for Augustine Birrell, I believe he retreated to that same depressed state of mind that enveloped him after the death of his first wife.

  I wrote about Birrell's marginalia in an essay, "Hither-unpublished Obiter Dicta," that was published in the 2011 Caxton Club book:  Other People's Books:  Association Copies and the Stories They Tell.  

As of this writing, Oak Knoll Books had at least twenty copies of this book still available.

Finally, Augustine Birrell created the title of his autobiography, Things Past Redress, from a line in Shakespeare's King Richard II.  I used the very same line to close my essay in Other People's Books....
And I will use the same line to close this here blog post:
"Things past redress are now with me past care."